Available for a limited time only - £10 off a £20 spend at eXpansys! For more details visit this topic!

Please Log In or Register - it's FREE!

2 Pages V   1 2 >  
Reply to this topicStart new topic
 Diamond and i900 face off at GSMArena
Rating 4 V
Paul (MVP)
post Jul 4 2008, 15:58
Post #1


The Main Man
Group Icon

Group: Admin Team
Posts: 20,598
Joined: 6th November 2002
From: Norwich, UK
Member No.: 1

Device(s): HTC Advantage



They're the two hottest devices at the moment... the HTC Diamond and the Samsung i900... and the chaps over at GSMArena have managed to get their hands on one of each and put them head to head!

As they say...

"It's PocketPC playoffs and HTC are giving Samsung a match at the GSM Arena. With two of the stars of the season arriving in our office all at once, we thought it's a heck of an opportunity for some Diamond-Omnia-Diamond-Omnia-Diamond-Omnia game-set-match with a pinch of iPhone flavor. We got two aces up to the challenge, so sit back and stretch out. Ah well, get that six-pack too and join us for the kick-off. ".

Heck, it's Friday, bring on the beer biggrin.gif

The article is well worth a read and is exceptionally thorough, running to 9 pages! I'm gonna post the conclusion here, because reading it doesn't negate the value of reading the full article.

QUOTE
Well, it's the final whistle in our head-to-head. Tempted as we are to not leave it a tie and send it to a penalty shootout, we just have to pay due respect to both contenders. After all it's not the score that makes the game exciting. Sometimes a draw can be as interesting to watch, and this one here sure ain't goalless.

Anyway, it's nearly impossible to give a conclusive judgment as to which of these two fine PocketPCs deserves your money better. The Samsung i900 Omnia and the HTC Touch Diamond are both excellent choices with their own set of advantages and shortcomings. The good thing is they hardly overlap, so getting your priorities right is all you need to make the right choice.

You can certainly get the short version of their virtues at the beginning of this review, we won't be repeating all of those here.

The main point to make here is that there isn't a perfect device that's got it all for all consumer groups even in this high-end segment. Instead, when you go after one of these extra sweet devices you should carefully weigh your priorities and pick the one that covers most of them.

iPhone 3G is still to see a reality check, but it's almost sure that these two can give the latest Apple device a good fight. Maybe they still can't challenge the iPhone interface, but they are finally getting closer.

With HTC Touch Diamond and Samsung i900 Omnia, Windows Mobile handsets no longer seem chubby and nerdy. The next generation of PocketPCs match style with the best performance in their class.

Thought this head to head was going to make your choice easier? Perhaps not! biggrin.gif

P

Link: HTC Touch Diamond vs. Samsung i900 Omnia: Head-to-Head


--------------------
Paul O'Brien - Microsoft MVP, Mobile Devices, MoDaCo.network Founder. Check out my Blog!

£10 off a £20 spend at eXpansys - click for details
Go to the top of the page
 
+Quote Post
rzanology
post Jul 5 2008, 08:17
Post #2


Newbie
Group Icon

Group: Posters
Posts: 2
Joined: 27th January 2005
Member No.: 107,149

Device(s): mpx 220



hurts my heart they didnt outfit the i900 with vga!!!! why!!!!! i reeeally hope att is picking up the xperia instead of this! other than the missing vga it looks like a great device.
Go to the top of the page
 
+Quote Post
awarner (MVP)
post Jul 5 2008, 13:20
Post #3


Staff Team Leader
Group Icon

Group: Admin Team
Posts: 17,051
Joined: 24th November 2002
From: Southampton
Member No.: 53

Device(s): C550 and JasJar



Better CPU performance, decent camera and double battery life on the i900 gets my vote.


--------------------
3 mobile where the words "customer" and "service" only exists in the dictionary

Smartphone and PocketPC History
SPV, E100, E200, C500, C550, C600 (MoDaCo Edition), MPX200, MPX220, MIO8380, Voq Pro, Lobster 700, JasJar, Vario

New and updated Smartphone History

Life's too fast can I get off and walk for a bit?
I used to be top poster.......
Go to the top of the page
 
+Quote Post
Ypocaramel
post Jul 6 2008, 02:47
Post #4


Newbie
Group Icon

Group: Posters
Posts: 6
Joined: 30th September 2007
Member No.: 305,827



I don't think it'll be that hard for most. 5MP camera, better battery life and more than 4GB of memory? Omnia. Flashy interface, snazzy looks and small size? Diamond.
Go to the top of the page
 
+Quote Post
amd7000
post Jul 6 2008, 11:24
Post #5


Newbie
Group Icon

Group: Posters
Posts: 11
Joined: 11th March 2008
Member No.: 366,385



Diamond plus an ultra mobile pc for me. This combo beats the omnia and probably cheaper? tongue.gif
Go to the top of the page
 
+Quote Post
awarner (MVP)
post Jul 6 2008, 11:48
Post #6


Staff Team Leader
Group Icon

Group: Admin Team
Posts: 17,051
Joined: 24th November 2002
From: Southampton
Member No.: 53

Device(s): C550 and JasJar



Don't think so, Omnia is being shown on the net as around the £500 mark for the 8GB version.
That is the initial release price so when it finally hits the shelves we will see.


--------------------
3 mobile where the words "customer" and "service" only exists in the dictionary

Smartphone and PocketPC History
SPV, E100, E200, C500, C550, C600 (MoDaCo Edition), MPX200, MPX220, MIO8380, Voq Pro, Lobster 700, JasJar, Vario

New and updated Smartphone History

Life's too fast can I get off and walk for a bit?
I used to be top poster.......
Go to the top of the page
 
+Quote Post
Dr Who
post Jul 6 2008, 11:49
Post #7


Timelord
Group Icon

Group: Posters
Posts: 1,590
Joined: 6th September 2003
From: Gallifrey
Member No.: 15,319




Shame about the screen res, otherwise the i900 would be the winner. Don't suppose it will appear on TMobile anyway, though.
Go to the top of the page
 
+Quote Post
awarner (MVP)
post Jul 6 2008, 11:56
Post #8


Staff Team Leader
Group Icon

Group: Admin Team
Posts: 17,051
Joined: 24th November 2002
From: Southampton
Member No.: 53

Device(s): C550 and JasJar



If there is no stylus slot then where do you store it?
The Samsung site states it comes with one.
http://omnia.samsungmobile.com/


--------------------
3 mobile where the words "customer" and "service" only exists in the dictionary

Smartphone and PocketPC History
SPV, E100, E200, C500, C550, C600 (MoDaCo Edition), MPX200, MPX220, MIO8380, Voq Pro, Lobster 700, JasJar, Vario

New and updated Smartphone History

Life's too fast can I get off and walk for a bit?
I used to be top poster.......
Go to the top of the page
 
+Quote Post
tasman
post Jul 6 2008, 15:07
Post #9


gotta start somewhere
Group Icon

Group: Posters
Posts: 61
Joined: 29th January 2005
From: Milton Keynes, UK
Member No.: 107,458

Device(s): iPhone 3G



QUOTE(awarner (MVP) @ Jul 6 2008, 12:56) *



Having to spin the phone around in the air like that to change from portrait to lanscape seems a bit much rolleyes.gif


--------------------
current phone .~::~. sold my soul to Cupertino
previous phones .~::~. T-Mobile Hermes with Black Satin ROM (ex Orange M3100), O2 Mini-S, SPV C500, loads of Nokias......
Go to the top of the page
 
+Quote Post
awarner (MVP)
post Jul 6 2008, 15:18
Post #10


Staff Team Leader
Group Icon

Group: Admin Team
Posts: 17,051
Joined: 24th November 2002
From: Southampton
Member No.: 53

Device(s): C550 and JasJar



Not seen the spin the phone but on the video in the facebook link on the site it shows it just being tilted from portrait to landscape and back again (about 1min 30sec into the link)
Click HERE for facebook clip


--------------------
3 mobile where the words "customer" and "service" only exists in the dictionary

Smartphone and PocketPC History
SPV, E100, E200, C500, C550, C600 (MoDaCo Edition), MPX200, MPX220, MIO8380, Voq Pro, Lobster 700, JasJar, Vario

New and updated Smartphone History

Life's too fast can I get off and walk for a bit?
I used to be top poster.......
Go to the top of the page
 
+Quote Post
Syphon Filter
post Jul 6 2008, 18:15
Post #11


Addict
Group Icon

Group: MoDaCo Ad Free
Posts: 740
Joined: 19th November 2003
From: London - UK
Member No.: 21,445

Device(s): HTC TyTN II



QUOTE(amd7000 @ Jul 6 2008, 12:24) *
Diamond plus an ultra mobile pc for me. This combo beats the omnia and probably cheaper? tongue.gif


Which UMPC do you have?

For my money, the higher screen res of the Diamond would win.
Go to the top of the page
 
+Quote Post
amd7000
post Jul 6 2008, 20:47
Post #12


Newbie
Group Icon

Group: Posters
Posts: 11
Joined: 11th March 2008
Member No.: 366,385



awarner (MVP)Posted Today, 11:48 Don't think so, Omnia is being shown on the net as around the £500 mark for the 8GB version.
That is the initial release price so when it finally hits the shelves we will see.


Arhhhh, why did you have to say that! Now I don't know what to do again. wink.gif


Go to the top of the page
 
+Quote Post
amd7000
post Jul 6 2008, 20:51
Post #13


Newbie
Group Icon

Group: Posters
Posts: 11
Joined: 11th March 2008
Member No.: 366,385



QUOTE(Syphon Filter @ Jul 6 2008, 18:15) *
Which UMPC do you have?

For my money, the higher screen res of the Diamond would win.



Not got one yet. Was thinking the new acer aspire one. Its not got amazing reviews but very tempted for the price.
Go to the top of the page
 
+Quote Post
Monolithix
post Jul 6 2008, 23:31
Post #14


Moderator - Boing!
Group Icon

Group: Admin Team
Posts: 8,579
Joined: 12th December 2002
From: Guildford, UK
Member No.: 993

Device(s): HTC TyTN II



Of all the new wash of UMPC's i'd have an Acer One, looks shiny!

As for the Diamond/Omnia phone-off, i don't think i could move away from the VGA gloriousness of the Diamonds screen now wink.gif


--------------------
This months MoDaCo WinMo Week device: the MWg Zinc II! Ask your questions HERE and download the show here!

2.25GB of backup storage online for free with Mozy! - https://mozy.com/?ref=VQ664H
Go to the top of the page
 
+Quote Post
efjay
post Jul 7 2008, 00:20
Post #15


Enthusiast
Group Icon

Group: Posters
Posts: 206
Joined: 9th March 2004
Member No.: 35,755



That screenshot doesnt show any advantage to the VGA screen on the Diamond, you can actually see more icons on the supposed "inferior" WQVGA screen on the Omnia. Screen size wins for me, plus 16GB storage, card slot, 5MP camera, haptic feedback and bigger battery.
Go to the top of the page
 
+Quote Post
capt_janeway
post Jul 7 2008, 07:59
Post #16


Diehard
Group Icon

Group: Posters
Posts: 349
Joined: 4th February 2003
From: London, UK
Member No.: 2,625

Device(s): S710, HTC Diamond



Any idea which UK carrier, if any, will get the i900?


--------------------
Beam me up to the Thicko Quandrant!!

No... You can't get away... From hell's heart I stab at thee...For hate's sake... I spit my last breath at thee!

Go to the top of the page
 
+Quote Post
Syphon Filter
post Jul 7 2008, 08:47
Post #17


Addict
Group Icon

Group: MoDaCo Ad Free
Posts: 740
Joined: 19th November 2003
From: London - UK
Member No.: 21,445

Device(s): HTC TyTN II



QUOTE(efjay @ Jul 7 2008, 01:20) *
That screenshot doesnt show any advantage to the VGA screen on the Diamond, you can actually see more icons on the supposed "inferior" WQVGA screen on the Omnia. Screen size wins for me, plus 16GB storage, card slot, 5MP camera, haptic feedback and bigger battery.


Think outside the box dude! What about web browsing etc. The screen will also be a lot crisper due to the increased DPI.
Go to the top of the page
 
+Quote Post
efjay
post Jul 7 2008, 10:46
Post #18


Enthusiast
Group Icon

Group: Posters
Posts: 206
Joined: 9th March 2004
Member No.: 35,755



QUOTE(Syphon Filter @ Jul 7 2008, 04:47) *
Think outside the box dude! What about web browsing etc. The screen will also be a lot crisper due to the increased DPI.


Yes, but if it doesnt display more information on the screen and only gives you advantages in certain apps I dont see it as such an advantage. I browse a lot as well but also use A2DP, have multiple GPS programs and read emails. The bigger screen space, battery and external slot are more important to me than VGA.
Go to the top of the page
 
+Quote Post
awarner (MVP)
post Jul 7 2008, 11:35
Post #19


Staff Team Leader
Group Icon

Group: Admin Team
Posts: 17,051
Joined: 24th November 2002
From: Southampton
Member No.: 53

Device(s): C550 and JasJar



Agree there, in the past I've seen qvga devices physically looking better than vga screens.
It's not always the resolution that makes the device.


--------------------
3 mobile where the words "customer" and "service" only exists in the dictionary

Smartphone and PocketPC History
SPV, E100, E200, C500, C550, C600 (MoDaCo Edition), MPX200, MPX220, MIO8380, Voq Pro, Lobster 700, JasJar, Vario

New and updated Smartphone History

Life's too fast can I get off and walk for a bit?
I used to be top poster.......
Go to the top of the page
 
+Quote Post
Syphon Filter
post Jul 7 2008, 12:33
Post #20


Addict
Group Icon

Group: MoDaCo Ad Free
Posts: 740
Joined: 19th November 2003
From: London - UK
Member No.: 21,445

Device(s): HTC TyTN II



QUOTE(efjay @ Jul 7 2008, 11:46) *
Yes, but if it doesnt display more information on the screen and only gives you advantages in certain apps I dont see it as such an advantage. I browse a lot as well but also use A2DP, have multiple GPS programs and read emails. The bigger screen space, battery and external slot are more important to me than VGA.



QUOTE(awarner (MVP) @ Jul 7 2008, 12:35) *
Agree there, in the past I've seen qvga devices physically looking better than vga screens.
It's not always the resolution that makes the device.


I would say it depends heavily on the DPI of the screen and how the OS has been configured.
Go to the top of the page
 
+Quote Post

2 Pages V   1 2 >
Reply to this topicStart new topic

Collapse

Similar Topics

  Topic Replies Topic Starter Views Last Action
No new Topic has attachmentsBlackjack III and 6.1 for Blackjack II to be released july
^^^^^^
43 xxa1rxforce1zxx 13,152 Today, 00:58
Last post by: sfleuriet
No new