MoDaCo is undergoing planned maintenance. Site functionality may be reduced - follow @modaco or @paulobrien on Twitter for updates.

  • Announcements

    • Reminder - MoDaCo position on illegal content

      ILLEGAL CONTENT I'd like to just reaffirm MoDaCo's position regarding piracy and illegal content in the light of some recent questions / postings. Posts will be censored by myself or my moderation team if the contain or link to: Illegal / pirated / cracked software or sites that host such software
      Nintendo emulators / ROMs or sites hosting them (in light of Nintendo's legal stance)


      CUSTOM ROMS

      You may discuss and post links to custom device ROMs on MoDaCo, provided the following rules are adhered to: ROMs must not be hosted directly in topic via the MoDaCo attachment system
      ROMs must not contain any illegal 3rd party software (this includes trial versions included without permission)
      ROMs must give full credit to the original author
      This decision has been taken in light of the huge amount of interest in this area of device customisation within the community, and member feedback! Please note that custom ROM discussion should be kept in specific device sub-areas, (e.g. Kaiser.MoDaCo.com for Kaiser based devices). ISSUES If you have any issues with this policy, please contact me directly via PM. P
    • Support MoDaCo by signing up to a MoDaCo Silver or Gold membership

      To sign up to an annual MoDaCo Silver subscription which will eliminate all ads from the site (as well as giving you access to the MoDaCo Online Kitchens for Android) for only £9.99 using PayPal, Credit or Debit Card, ensure you are logged in to the site, and then click the link below, which will take you directly to the subscription store! You can also sign up to an annual MoDaCo Gold subscription for £29.99, which adds the benefits listed below! PURCHASE A MODACO SUBSCRIPTION - FREE Titanium Backup Mobile for Android worth $5.99! - FREE 1 year PrivateInternetAccess.com worth $39.95! - FREE 1 year LastPass Premium worth $12! - FREE CalcConvert for Pocket PC from Binaryfish worth $17.95! - FREE Calendar Bar for Pocket PC from OmegaOne worth $9.99! - FREE CamerAware for Pocket PC and Smartphone from MoDaCo worth £19.99 / $30! - FREE Chronos for Pocket PC from ActiveKitten worth $14.95! - FREE CodeWallet Pro for Smartphone and Pocket PC from DeveloperOne worth up to $24.95! - FREE Concentrix for Pocket PC from eSoft Interactive worth $9.95! - FREE FlexMail for Pocket PC and Smartphone from WebIS worth up to $59.90! - FREE FTouchSL for Pocket PC from Vekoff s.r.o. worth 10 euro / $12.50! - FREE Jewel Challenge for Pocket PC from eSoft Interactive worth $9.95! - FREE John Cody's Alerts Pro for Smartphone from Omnisoft worth $14.95! - FREE LingvoSoft Talking Dictionary 2008 English <-> Dutch for Pocket PC from Lingvosoft worth $49.95! - FREE LingvoSoft Talking Dictionary 2008 English <-> French for Pocket PC from Lingvosoft worth $49.95! - FREE LingvoSoft Talking Dictionary 2008 English <-> German for Pocket PC from Lingvosoft worth $49.95! - FREE LingvoSoft Talking Dictionary 2008 English <-> Italian for Pocket PC from Lingvosoft worth $49.95! - FREE LingvoSoft Talking Dictionary 2008 English <-> Spanish for Pocket PC from Lingvosoft worth $49.95! - FREE LingvoSoft Dictionary English <-> Dutch for Smartphone from Lingvosoft worth $49.95! - FREE LingvoSoft Dictionary English <-> French for Smartphone from Lingvosoft worth $49.95! - FREE LingvoSoft Dictionary English <-> German for Smartphone from Lingvosoft worth $49.95! - FREE LingvoSoft Dictionary English <-> Russian for Smartphone from Lingvosoft worth $49.95! - FREE LingvoSoft Dictionary English <-> Turkish for Smartphone from Lingvosoft worth $49.95! - FREE Note2Self for Pocket PC and Smartphone from WebIS worth up to $19.90! - FREE Opera 8.60 for Pocket PC and Smartphone from Opera Software worth up to $48! - FREE Pocket Informant for Pocket PC and Smartphone from WebIS worth up to $59.90! - FREE Pocket Launcher for Pocket PC and Smartphone from Conduits worth $9.95! - FREE PTab for Pocket PC and Smartphone from z4soft worth up to $60! - FREE Resco Explorer for Pocket PC and Smartphone from Resco worth up to $49.90! - FREE Safemode for Pocket PC from monocube worth $12.95 - FREE SplashPhoto for Pocket PC and Smartphone from SplashData worth up to $59.90! - FREE Sprite Backup for Pocket PC and Smartphone from Sprite Software worth $29.95! - FREE Teksoft Glyphs UI for Pocket PC and Smartphone from Teksoft €9.95! - FREE Teksoft HeadsetRemote for Pocket PC and Smartphone from Teksoft €4.95! - FREE Traffic Jam for Pocket PC from eSoft Interactive worth $9.95! - FREE unlock (1 per year) from imei-check.co.uk - DISCOUNT of 10% at MoDaCo FairDeal - DISCOUNT of 10% at Semsons.com - FORUM - AD FREE SITE - FORUM - custom rank / title - FORUM - double competition entries - FORUM - double post attachment space - FORUM - no search flood control - FORUM - priority event registration - FORUM - triple PM space
    • Reminder: Selling items on the forum directly is not allowed

      Please note that selling items on the forum directly is not allowed by the forum rules. There is a forum for eBay auctions whereby you can list the items on eBay and link to them there. This is the ONLY forum for this type of activity. You may also advertise links to the eBay forum in your signature. Please note that selling directly in contravention of these rules will result in a warning / suspensions / ban.

Should a reviewer be rewarded for a good review, and who pays for samples?

4 posts in this topic

Posted (edited) · Report post

Okay. This is a thread for Paul, preferably, or someone else in the profession of doing professional reviews of tech devices - if you want to give an opinion then fine, but don't cast judgements or aspersions - they are likely to come forth, but serve no purpose. My questions are these:

1/ Should a good reviewer be rewarded for a good review (I mean a YouTube review, full HD, no silent Charlie Chaplin-esque nonsense with just someone's hands fumbling an "unboxing" in 360p).

2/ When high profile PR agencies hand out sample stock of handsets, who pays for the samples? Are they factored into the manufacturer's corporate marketing budget?

The reason I ask this is that I have reviewed many things over the years - I was once given almost £1,500 of Mac Pro RAM to review, and afterwards told to keep it. Likewise for a graphics card I reviewed, a games console... etc etc. I know some companies ask for stock back - I'm just wondering if they'd be less inclined to do so if the review were a really good one (note: by "good" I do not mean intentionally favouring the device [lying] JUST so I get rewarded - I mean even if it turns out the device is terribly bad, an honest review can still be a "good" review - well constructed etc).

I don't expect to be rewarded, I am merely asking what Paul and others think about one's time spent on doing a review - I am about to do a review of a VERY cheap handset, and the time it will take is negligible, but the publicity it will provide for the manufacturer will be good for their sales (my YouTube channel has well over 1M hits - not massive by YouTube standards, but nothing to sniff at!).

How would you approach the company, post-review, to see if I get to keep the device? If I have to give it back, that's cool - just wondered.

Thanks :)

Edited by glossywhite
0

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Posted · Report post

Some people do reviews just to get their hands on the latest tech other because they generally like a product and want to share their experience.

If the profile is high enough ie page hits etc and the quality of the review is well written and preferably not biased to cover certain aspects then it will get noticed by manufactures or suppliers and so be approached in the future.

Regarding handsets this can be more complicated, depending on the site or person in question and the budget of the company department at the time will govern if the review item will be a loner or one to keep. Some devices are passed around to a few people and if you are at the end on the line you may also be lucky to keep it.

The one factor you did not account for is quite a few sites and reviewers actually buy their own devices to review and then rely on advertising or donations to cover the costs.

It can also be who you are and being in the right place at the right time.

Remember these companies get hundreds of begging letters asking for review devices, getting your foot in the door is the hard part. Once you have a device if will normally be discussed about returning or keeping it, some companies will only allow you to have a device for a few days.

1

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Posted · Report post

1/ Should a good reviewer be rewarded for a good review (I mean a YouTube review, full HD, no silent Charlie Chaplin-esque nonsense with just someone's hands fumbling an "unboxing" in 360p).

What do you mean by rewarded, and by whom? I wouldn't really expect the reviewer to be rewarded by the company in question. It is up to the reviewer themselves to determine their motivation for doing a review, be that financial, exposure or something else. For example, you might do a review on YouTube and use their tools to monetise it, post a text review somewhere with ads or use it as good exposure for your 'CV' or similar.

2/ When high profile PR agencies hand out sample stock of handsets, who pays for the samples? Are they factored into the manufacturer's corporate marketing budget?

They are generally speaking supplied by the manufacturer who yes, probably factors them in to the marketing budget.

Two things to bear in mind. 1 - if you want a timely review, pretty often nowadays you're better off sourcing a device yourself rather than waiting for the PR people to get you one... companies are notoriously bad at putting their PR co before their customers. :) 2 - pretty much nobody allows you to keep devices. They are sent to you on a loan basis for you to review, then sent back and sent on to the next person. In some very rare cases you might get a device to keep, but that is a VERY rare case.

By far the best way to review devices is to find them cheap, use them a bit while keeping them in mint condition, write the review then sell them on at hopefully no loss to fund the next review device. That's what I generally do now.

Finally, bear in mind that a lot of publications don't allow reviewers to keep devices for ethical reasons, another reason why it's a generally accepted practice that they are returned.

P

1

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Posted · Report post

Thank you "awarner", thank you Paul; your advice is valuable to me :)

0

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!


Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.


Sign In Now

MoDaCo is part of the MoDaCo.network, © Paul O'Brien 2002-2015. MoDaCo uses IntelliTxt technology.