Jump to content


Photo

WM7 v Android 2

- - - - -

  • Please log in to reply
7 replies to this topic

#1
pd.ryder

pd.ryder

    Hardcore

  • Members
  • PipPipPipPipPipPip
  • 1,308 posts
  • Gender:Male
  • Location:Gloucestershire, UK
  • Interests:Gadgets, gadgets, gadgets!!! Those aside, riding motorbikes, MotoGP & WSBK, clay pigeon shooting, martial arts - karate, aikido, Enshin Ryu iaido (sword), bo, battons etc, digital photography, Hi-Fi (currently Arcam/Linn setup), home cinema (Oh, and psychiatric nursing - but that's just work!)
  • Devices:HTC One (M8), Galaxy Nexus
  • Twitter:@pdryder
Here's the deal guys:

I've had a WinMo phone / device / gadget since the Canary first came along. I'm about to upgrade despite it not being due until September.

T-Mo have offered me a super deal (that is very tempting) on a shiny new HTC Desire.

The thing is -- should I take the 2yr deal for a tidy Android 2-point-something device or hold out for WinMo7, knowing full well it will be chock full of problems, anomalies and prone to constant crashing. How long would it take for the WM7 devices to start to shine I wonder. Lets face it, WinMo has never really grabbed the masses by the throat compared with the (in my opinion) hugely flawed iPhone. Even the Android OS seemed to have many more "fans" shortly after launch than WinMo ever seemed to have in all these years.

Is the Desire worth the trade-off? Is WM7 "that good"? And will I be able to look myself in the eye in the morning?

Your thoughts...?

  • 0
HTC One (M8), big shiny sword...

"What happens to a politician if you give him Viagra?
He gets taller" - Jesse Duke, Hazzard County

#2
keri2000

keri2000

    Newbie

  • Members
  • Pip
  • 1 posts
  • Devices:xv6900

Here's the deal guys:

I've had a WinMo phone / device / gadget since the Canary first came along. I'm about to upgrade despite it not being due until September.

T-Mo have offered me a super deal (that is very tempting) on a shiny new HTC Desire.

The thing is -- should I take the 2yr deal for a tidy Android 2-point-something device or hold out for WinMo7, knowing full well it will be chock full of problems, anomalies and prone to constant crashing. How long would it take for the WM7 devices to start to shine I wonder. Lets face it, WinMo has never really grabbed the masses by the throat compared with the (in my opinion) hugely flawed iPhone. Even the Android OS seemed to have many more "fans" shortly after launch than WinMo ever seemed to have in all these years.

Is the Desire worth the trade-off? Is WM7 "that good"? And will I be able to look myself in the eye in the morning?

Your thoughts...?


How often can you upgrade? I have the luxury of upgrading 1 time per year with Sprint. I have also decided after purchasing a launch day Palm Pre that I won't ever be a smartphone beta tester again. ;) With that said I feel that WebOS took a good 8 months to mature to a customer ready level. It still has issues though.

Anyway I really am in the same boat as you because I also would like a Windows 7 phone but I have decided in June to pick up the Evo and let Windows 7 phones settle in and mature until next June when I am ready to upgrade again. I would like to see what other people think. Will WP7 be ready upon release? I am jaded after the Pre issues I have had...

Edited by keri2000, 17 April 2010 - 04:24 PM.

  • 0

#3
awarner

awarner

    Staff Team Leader

  • Admin Team
  • PipPipPipPipPipPip
  • 18,506 posts
  • Gender:Male
  • Location:Southampton
  • Interests:Life the universe and everything in it :)

    Lumia 925 one hell of a camera phone
  • Devices:Lumia 925 a real phone at last
  • Twitter:@ashwarner
Technically the new WP7 should be spot on right from the start as such as it is a complete redesign.
If there are problems will the platform for the phone format survive or will it be back to the business handhelds from where it started?

Fingers crossed for me, lets hope that the Windows phone department have finally listened to the end user and not kept the ideas inhouse only.

  • 0
Twitter me @ashwarner

Windows Phone 7 Expert.
Windows Phone Business Specialist



#4
pd.ryder

pd.ryder

    Hardcore

  • Members
  • PipPipPipPipPipPip
  • 1,308 posts
  • Gender:Male
  • Location:Gloucestershire, UK
  • Interests:Gadgets, gadgets, gadgets!!! Those aside, riding motorbikes, MotoGP & WSBK, clay pigeon shooting, martial arts - karate, aikido, Enshin Ryu iaido (sword), bo, battons etc, digital photography, Hi-Fi (currently Arcam/Linn setup), home cinema (Oh, and psychiatric nursing - but that's just work!)
  • Devices:HTC One (M8), Galaxy Nexus
  • Twitter:@pdryder
My shiny new Desire will land one day this week - once the upgrade dept is allocated their stock. I assume I'll have the usual cooling-off period within which I can change my mind and send it back?

I'm hoping, of course, that it'll do what I want how I want when I want. Rather than when it suits itself like my current HD. There's nothing wrong with the HD - its lovely and generally performs well.

But.

Once I have 3 apps running using 60%+ of resources it generally slows to a crawl. It needs soft resetting every day, if not twice a day, if I really ask it to work hard. I spend most of my mobile time Tweeting via moTweet, emailing and FB, some MSN via Palringo and browsing with Skyfire. I've always been underwhelmed with the browsing experience no matter what I've used. Laggy, unresponsive and oh-so-slow especially with the likes of Opera.

By all accounts, this Desire will fit the bill - hopefully anyway :}

  • 0
HTC One (M8), big shiny sword...

"What happens to a politician if you give him Viagra?
He gets taller" - Jesse Duke, Hazzard County

#5
awarner

awarner

    Staff Team Leader

  • Admin Team
  • PipPipPipPipPipPip
  • 18,506 posts
  • Gender:Male
  • Location:Southampton
  • Interests:Life the universe and everything in it :)

    Lumia 925 one hell of a camera phone
  • Devices:Lumia 925 a real phone at last
  • Twitter:@ashwarner
The main thing that stops me using an Android device for everyday use is that you can not sync with Outlook unless you go through google.
I have zero faith in googles security especially as they are renown for collecting user data and so i would never trust them to handle any part of my email.

  • 0
Twitter me @ashwarner

Windows Phone 7 Expert.
Windows Phone Business Specialist



#6
andrew.mazlim

andrew.mazlim

    Hardcore

  • Members
  • PipPipPipPipPipPip
  • 1,588 posts
  • Gender:Male
  • Location:Great Britain
  • Interests:Footie, rock music, books, films.
  • Devices:T-Mobile USA HTC HD2 Leo
Stay on target, mate. Stick on W7s.

  • 0
Posted Image

T-Mobile USA .HTC HD2 Leo
________________________________________________________________________________

Firmware: NRGZ28's "ENERGY-Dinik" Build: 29020
Radio:..........2.15.50.14

My "OMNIA i900 GOODS/TWEAKS/TOOLS/APPs" thread:
http://www.modaco.co...ilitiesvisuals/
My "OMNIA i900 M2D/S2U2 Ultimate England Theme" thread:
http://www.modaco.co...artup-m2d-s2u2/

#7
Menneisyys

Menneisyys

    Hardcore

  • Moderator Team
  • PipPipPipPipPipPip
  • 1,038 posts
  • Devices:a lot
I think it's a bit early to announce a winner. Android could do better (the iPhone still has FAR better 3rd party software support and is, generally, a much friendlier op. system) so I think WP7 will have an easy time beating Android. Unless there won't be third party apps at all for WP7, of course.

  • 0

#8
pd.ryder

pd.ryder

    Hardcore

  • Members
  • PipPipPipPipPipPip
  • 1,308 posts
  • Gender:Male
  • Location:Gloucestershire, UK
  • Interests:Gadgets, gadgets, gadgets!!! Those aside, riding motorbikes, MotoGP & WSBK, clay pigeon shooting, martial arts - karate, aikido, Enshin Ryu iaido (sword), bo, battons etc, digital photography, Hi-Fi (currently Arcam/Linn setup), home cinema (Oh, and psychiatric nursing - but that's just work!)
  • Devices:HTC One (M8), Galaxy Nexus
  • Twitter:@pdryder

The main thing that stops me using an Android device for everyday use is that you can not sync with Outlook unless you go through google.
I have zero faith in googles security especially as they are renown for collecting user data and so i would never trust them to handle any part of my email.

I think the Orwellian paranoia can get in the way sometimes. I've used Google Sync on Outlook for a long time already. I have my work email (via NHS.net), home Sky a/c, Gmail and Hotmail all sync'd via several plugins and connectors. I should be able to use my SKoogle mail a/c directly with Android due to Sky using Google's servers, plus the Gmail a/c etc, etc...

I can't see the problem personally. If some twit somewhere keeps a log of my obscure Google searches or even a list of my Gmails - I really don't give a hoot. The option to save a history of every page I've browsed or searched is, periodically, a bonus because I can access it from any machine in the world, mobile or otherwise.

I just wish there was a stock of these HTC Desire devices. Retentions (at T-Mo), upgrades (ditto) nor the local shop have any stock at all and have no idea when they will.

Dismal :huh:

  • 0
HTC One (M8), big shiny sword...

"What happens to a politician if you give him Viagra?
He gets taller" - Jesse Duke, Hazzard County




0 user(s) are reading this topic

0 members, 0 guests, 0 anonymous users