Hmm .. have you tried re-downloading just in case you got a corrupted .zip somehow? Nobody else has reported any problem like yours, so it must be an issue with the download, your particular device, or ..well don't know beyond that :/
Keep me posted on your progress
I redownloaded zip to be sure that problem is not with it.
Could be something wrong with my phone as you mentioned,
but I reinstalled SS4 rom with no problems, also with circlemod.
I want to have good looking rom with your theme, but now dont want to try to reinstall it again,
lost already couple of hours trying to get this one running
Will let you know if I get it working eventually.