Froyo: Move2SD instead of A2SD?

[Guest Master One]

I'm trying to familiarize myself with Android as quickly as possible, before I replace the stock 2.1 on my new ZTE Blade with the latest 2.2, and stumbled across the suggestion to use Move2SD instead of A2SD.

Afaik A2SD is now included in Froyo, and Move2SD is available in the market. A2SD needs a separate ext2/3 partition, whereas Move2SD works with the normal FAT partition. Move2SD needs root, is this a downside?

Does A2SD have any advantage over Move2SD?

Is Move2SD the superior solution?

[Guest Azurren]

Froyo can move "enabled" apps to the SD card as default

There are ways of forcing apps that aren't "Enabled" to the SD as well by using 3rd party apps

A2SD can be faster in some cases.. But reliability is suspect and it is complicated to manage

If you want a smooth android experience then just use the stock Froyo solution

Edited December 27, 2010 by Azurren